Pasta. That comforting, versatile dish that can be as simple as a perfectly cooked spaghetti aglio e olio or as elaborate as a lobster ravioli in a creamy saffron sauce. Jamaica, NY, boasts a surprisingly diverse culinary scene, and within that scene lies a treasure trove of excellent pasta restaurants. This guide dives into twelve of the best, offering a delicious journey through different styles, tastes, and price points. Whether you're craving classic Italian, inventive fusion, or a casual, comforting meal, you'll find something to satisfy your pasta cravings here.
Top Picks for Pasta Perfection in Jamaica, NY
This list isn't ranked – each restaurant excels in its own way. The best choice for you will depend on your preferences and budget.
1. Bella Mia Trattoria: A Taste of Italy in Jamaica
Bella Mia is a neighborhood gem, known for its authentic Italian recipes and warm, inviting atmosphere. Their pasta dishes are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, and their sauces are bursting with flavor. Don't miss their signature lasagna – it's a local favorite! They offer a wide array of pasta choices, including gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.
- Speciality: Classic Italian pasta dishes with a focus on fresh ingredients.
- Price range: Moderate
- Atmosphere: Cozy and inviting
2. Pasta Perfection: Where the Name Says It All
As the name suggests, Pasta Perfection prioritizes, well, pasta perfection! They offer a constantly rotating menu featuring both traditional and innovative pasta creations. Their use of seasonal ingredients ensures that each dish is fresh and flavorful. They're particularly known for their innovative takes on classic sauces.
- Specialty: Creative pasta dishes with seasonal ingredients.
- Price range: Moderate to High
- Atmosphere: Modern and upscale
3. Luigi's Italian Restaurant: A Jamaica Institution
Luigi's has been a Jamaica staple for years. They are a classic Italian restaurant with a reputation for generous portions and consistent quality. Their pasta dishes are comforting and satisfying, perfect for a family meal or a casual night out. They're well-known for their welcoming atmosphere and friendly service.
- Specialty: Traditional Italian-American pasta dishes, large portions.
- Price range: Moderate
- Atmosphere: Classic and familiar
4. Giovanni's Ristorante: Romantic Ambiance and Exquisite Pasta
For a more romantic and upscale dining experience, Giovanni's is the place to go. They offer a sophisticated menu with a focus on high-quality ingredients and elegant presentation. Their pasta dishes are works of art, both in terms of taste and appearance. Perfect for a special occasion.
- Specialty: Upscale Italian pasta dishes, elegant presentation.
- Price range: High
- Atmosphere: Romantic and sophisticated
5. Mama Rosa's: Home-Style Italian Cooking
Mama Rosa's serves up delicious, home-style Italian cooking, including a wide array of pasta dishes. Think rich, flavorful sauces, generous portions, and a family-friendly atmosphere. Their prices are extremely reasonable, making this a great option for budget-conscious diners.
- Specialty: Comfort food Italian pasta, generous portions, affordable.
- Price range: Low to Moderate
- Atmosphere: Casual and family-friendly
6. Salvatore's: A Hidden Gem
Salvatore's is a bit of a hidden gem. Their menu is smaller than some of the other restaurants on this list, but that's because they focus on perfecting every dish. Their pasta dishes are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and are cooked to perfection.
- Specialty: Simple, expertly-made pasta dishes.
- Price range: Moderate
- Atmosphere: Intimate and cozy
7. The Pasta House: A Wide Variety of Choices
The Pasta House offers an incredibly wide variety of pasta dishes, from classic spaghetti carbonara to more adventurous creations. There's something for everyone on their menu, making this a great option for groups with diverse tastes. Their extensive wine list is a nice added bonus.
- Specialty: Wide variety of pasta dishes to suit all tastes.
- Price range: Moderate
- Atmosphere: Lively and bustling
8. Nonna's Kitchen: Taste of Grandma's Cooking
Nonna's Kitchen serves up comforting, home-style Italian food reminiscent of a grandmother's kitchen. Their pasta dishes are simple, yet incredibly flavorful, reflecting the love and care that goes into their preparation. This is a perfect place for a warm and comforting meal.
- Specialty: Traditional Italian home-style cooking, family recipes
- Price range: Low to Moderate
- Atmosphere: Warm and family-friendly
9. Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant: More Than Just Pizza
While known for its pizza, Little Italy also serves up some seriously delicious pasta dishes. They offer a good balance of classic and more modern options, making it a versatile choice for pasta lovers. Their location is convenient and they offer takeout and delivery.
- Specialty: Classic Italian-American fare, including excellent pasta dishes.
- Price range: Low to Moderate
- Atmosphere: Casual and convenient
10. Anthony's Pizzeria: Another Great Pizza Place with Pasta
Similar to Little Italy, Anthony's is primarily a pizzeria, but their pasta sides and entrees are worth a try. They offer simple, well-executed pasta dishes that complement their pizza offerings perfectly. It’s a great casual option for a quick bite or a family meal.
- Specialty: Simple and tasty pasta dishes alongside excellent pizzas.
- Price range: Low to Moderate
- Atmosphere: Casual and family-friendly
11. Pasta Fresca: Fresh Pasta, Made Daily
Pasta Fresca focuses on using fresh, handmade pasta in all their dishes. The difference is noticeable, with a delightful texture and subtle flavor that elevates each dish. This is a great place to experience the difference that truly fresh pasta makes.
- Specialty: Fresh, handmade pasta dishes.
- Price range: Moderate to High
- Atmosphere: Casual yet refined
12. Angelo's Ristorante: Elegant Italian Cuisine
Angelo's is an elegant Italian restaurant offering a refined dining experience. Their pasta dishes are expertly prepared and creatively presented. It’s an ideal choice for a special occasion or a celebratory dinner.
- Specialty: Elegant and innovative pasta dishes.
- Price range: High
- Atmosphere: Upscale and refined
Finding Your Perfect Pasta in Jamaica, NY
This list provides a starting point for exploring the diverse pasta offerings in Jamaica, NY. Each restaurant offers a unique experience, so consider your budget, desired atmosphere, and preferred style of pasta when making your selection. Remember to check their websites or call ahead for menus, hours of operation, and any special offers. Enjoy your culinary adventure!
