The Theater District in NYC is a whirlwind of dazzling lights, captivating performances, and… surprisingly delicious burgers. After a Broadway show, or even just a day of exploring Times Square, a juicy burger is the perfect reward. This guide navigates the best burger joints in the area, ensuring you find the perfect post-show (or pre-show!) bite. We’ve considered quality of ingredients, bun-to-patty ratio, unique offerings, and overall experience to bring you this curated list of the top 10 burgers in NYC's Theater District.
Top 10 Burger Joints Near Broadway
This list isn't ranked in a strict order – all these spots deserve a spot on your must-try list! Each offers a unique burger experience, catering to different tastes and budgets.
1. Shake Shack (Multiple Locations): A NYC institution, Shake Shack needs no introduction. Their classic ShackBurger is consistently delicious, with its juicy patty, melted cheese, and special sauce. The crinkle-cut fries are a must-have addition. They often have limited-time offerings that keep things exciting, and their Theater District location offers a convenient pre- or post-show option.
2. The Smith (Multiple Locations): Known for its upscale-casual ambiance, The Smith offers a fantastic burger with a gourmet twist. Expect high-quality ingredients, perfectly cooked patties, and creative toppings. Their burger selection often changes, ensuring variety and keeping the menu exciting.
3. Bill's Bar & Burger (Multiple Locations): This spot is all about the classics done right. Bill's offers a simple yet satisfying burger experience. They emphasize fresh, high-quality ingredients and prioritize a great burger-eating experience. Their selection of gourmet toppings allows you to customize your burger to perfection.
4. Becco (Theater District): While known for its Italian cuisine, Becco also offers a surprisingly delicious burger that's a hidden gem among the Theater District's culinary offerings. Don't let the Italian focus deceive you – their burger is worth a try!
5. Junior's Restaurant (Downtown Brooklyn): While slightly outside the immediate Theater District, a short subway ride to Downtown Brooklyn rewards you with Junior's iconic burger. This is a classic diner experience, and their burger is legendary for its juiciness and generous size.
6. Bar Centrale (Midtown West): A lively and popular spot near the Theater District, Bar Centrale offers a satisfying burger to fuel your evening. They're popular for their vibrant atmosphere, but their burger shouldn't be overlooked!
7. Virgil's Real Barbecue (Times Square): If you want a burger with a Southern twist, Virgil's is your place. They offer juicy burgers with barbecue-inspired toppings and sides. This is a great option for those wanting something beyond the standard burger fare.
8. Ellen's Stardust Diner (Times Square): This unique diner is known for its singing waiters, but their burgers are surprisingly good, too! It's a fun, lively place to enjoy a meal before or after a show.
9. The Lambs Club (Midtown West): This upscale option presents a more refined burger experience. Expect higher price point, but also exceptionally high-quality ingredients and a sophisticated atmosphere.
10. Carmine's (Times Square): Similar to Becco, Carmine's is primarily known for Italian fare, but their burger is a hidden gem worth exploring. It's a great option if you're with a group, as they specialize in family-style dining.
Finding the Perfect Burger for Your Broadway Night
Choosing the right burger depends on your preferences and the overall tone of your evening.
| Restaurant | Style | Price Range | Ambiance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shake Shack | Classic Fast Casual | $ | Casual, Fast-Paced |
| The Smith | Upscale Casual | $ | Stylish, Lively |
| Bill's Bar & Burger | Classic Diner | $ | Casual, Relaxed |
| Becco | Hidden Gem (Italian) | $$ | Upscale Italian |
| Junior's | Classic Diner | $ | Classic Diner Vibe |
Remember to check restaurant websites for hours, menus, and reservation policies, especially for popular spots like The Smith or Becco. Enjoy your delicious Broadway burger!
