Finding the perfect roasted chicken can be a culinary quest. Whether you crave crispy skin, juicy meat, or a flavorful marinade, Staten Island offers a surprising variety of options. This guide dives into 18 of the best places to satisfy your roasted chicken cravings, highlighting their unique offerings and what makes them stand out. We'll cover everything from classic rotisserie styles to innovative twists on this timeless dish.
Top Spots for Classic Roasted Chicken
This section focuses on establishments known for their traditional, perfectly roasted chickens.
1. Joe's Rotisserie Chicken: A Staten Island Staple
Joe's has been a Staten Island institution for decades, perfecting the art of the simple, delicious roasted chicken. Their secret? A carefully balanced blend of herbs and spices, slow-roasted to perfection. Expect crispy skin and incredibly juicy meat. They also offer sides like mashed potatoes and gravy, making it a complete meal.
What sets them apart: Consistent quality and a friendly, neighborhood atmosphere.
2. Tony's Takeout: Family Recipe, Family Favorite
Tony's prides itself on its family recipe, passed down through generations. This results in a uniquely seasoned chicken with a subtly sweet and savory flavor profile. Many locals consider their roasted chicken a Sunday dinner staple.
What sets them apart: The unique family recipe and generous portion sizes.
3. Rosie's Chicken Shack: A Hidden Gem
While not as widely known as some others, Rosie's is a true hidden gem. Their roasted chickens are consistently tender, with a perfectly browned crust. They often have daily specials that include various sides and sauces.
What sets them apart: Excellent value and consistently delicious chicken.
4. The Chicken Coop: Fresh, Local, and Flavorful
The Chicken Coop prioritizes locally sourced ingredients, resulting in high-quality, flavorful roasted chickens. They often rotate their seasoning blends, offering a unique experience with each visit. Their commitment to freshness is evident in the taste.
What sets them apart: Their commitment to local sourcing and creative flavor combinations.
5. Primo's Poultry: Simple Perfection
Primo's keeps it simple, focusing on the quality of the chicken and the roasting process. Their birds are consistently cooked to perfection, with juicy meat and incredibly crispy skin. No frills, just great roasted chicken.
What sets them apart: Uncomplicated excellence and great value for the price.
Beyond the Basics: Unique Roasted Chicken Experiences
This section explores places offering unique variations on the classic roasted chicken.
6. The Gilded Lily: Gourmet Roasted Chicken
The Gilded Lily elevates the roasted chicken experience, offering gourmet variations with unique marinades and accompaniments. Expect sophisticated flavors and a higher price point to match.
What sets them apart: Upscale ambiance and creative flavor profiles.
7. Basil's Bistro: Mediterranean Flair
Basil's Bistro infuses its roasted chickens with Mediterranean herbs and spices, creating a flavorful and aromatic dish. The chicken is often served with a side of lemon-herb potatoes or a Greek salad.
What sets them apart: The Mediterranean-inspired seasoning and flavorful sides.
8. South Shore Grill: Southern Comfort Food
South Shore Grill offers a Southern twist on the roasted chicken, with options like BBQ-glazed chicken or chicken fried steak. Their sides complement the Southern-inspired flavors perfectly.
What sets them apart: Southern-style flavors and generous portions.
9. The Crabby Mermaid: Seafood and Chicken Perfection
While primarily a seafood restaurant, The Crabby Mermaid offers a surprisingly delicious roasted chicken. Their unique seasoning blend highlights the natural flavors of the chicken.
What sets them apart: Unexpectedly great chicken in a seafood-focused environment.
Fast Casual & Convenient Options
This section focuses on places offering quick and convenient access to roasted chicken.
10. Chick-fil-A (Staten Island locations): A Fast Food Favorite
While not strictly a "roasted" chicken, Chick-fil-A's grilled chicken options provide a lighter and healthier alternative. Their consistent quality and convenient locations make them a popular choice.
What sets them apart: Speed, consistency, and family-friendly atmosphere.
11. Popeyes (Staten Island locations): Spicy Southern Style
Popeyes offers a spicy take on fried chicken, which may not be roasted, but offers a convenient fast-food option if you're looking for something similar in style.
What sets them apart: Spice, convenience, and a unique flavor profile.
Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
This section highlights those lesser-known but highly-regarded options for roasted chicken.
12. Mama Rose's Kitchen: Home-style Cooking
Mama Rose's offers a true home-style roasted chicken experience, with flavorful seasoning and generous portions. It's a local favorite for those seeking comfort food.
What sets them apart: Authentic home-style cooking and a welcoming atmosphere.
13. Luigi's Deli: Unexpected Chicken Delight
Luigi's Deli isn't primarily known for its roasted chicken, but they offer a surprisingly delicious option, often featured in their daily specials.
What sets them apart: An unexpected find offering high-quality roasted chicken.
14. Sal's Pizzeria: More Than Just Pizza
Sal's Pizzeria might surprise you with their surprisingly good roasted chicken, often served as a side or part of a combo meal.
What sets them apart: An unexpected delicious option at a classic pizzeria.
Beyond the Traditional: Exploring Unique Styles
This section covers establishments offering innovative or non-traditional roasted chicken preparations.
15. The Tuscan Table: Italian-Inspired Roasted Chicken
The Tuscan Table brings Italian flair to their roasted chicken preparations, often incorporating herbs, vegetables, and citrus fruits.
What sets them apart: Elegant Italian-inspired flavors and presentation.
16. The Caribbean Grill: Island Flavors
The Caribbean Grill adds a tropical twist, using Caribbean spices and marinades to create a flavorful roasted chicken with a unique kick.
What sets them apart: The vibrant Caribbean flavors and spices.
Expanding Your Search: Delivery and Catering Options
This section covers services offering convenient access to roasted chicken.
17. DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub: Delivery Services
Numerous delivery services offer roasted chicken from various Staten Island restaurants, providing convenience and variety.
What sets them apart: The convenience of ordering and having your meal delivered.
18. Local Catering Services: For Larger Gatherings
Many local catering services include roasted chicken options for parties and events, providing a stress-free way to feed a crowd.
What sets them apart: Convenience and catering options for larger groups.
This list offers a comprehensive look at the best places for roasted chicken in Staten Island. Remember to check restaurant websites or call ahead to confirm hours, menus, and availability. Enjoy your culinary adventure!
